RE: Stan Weinstein's Stage Analysis
(2018-08-27, 10:29 PM)BarnabeBear Wrote: Thanks Isa for your posts, I find your custom charts extremely interesting.
Have you tried to chart them alongside the indices to see how this indicator behaves as an early warning sign for the DJIA/NDX/SPX?
By the way during the hols I've read Dorsey's P&F book: very verbose and extremely marketing-oriented to get you to subscribe to his website BUT regardless a very interesting read on P&F that I had not really gotten into so far.
So thanks a lot also for pointing me in this direction. I love it that it is very boolean and not open for discussion: has it double topped or not ? Hence the interest of what you're doing with this, ie building a database for all stocks. Very astute. You've opened up a whole world for me. Thanks again.
It is a constant sales pitch to get you onto his service, but like you said, none the less it does present some very interesting ways of using P&F charting which complements Weinsteins' method, i.e. the relative strength charting of the sectors and stocks against their peers etc. As it gives a systematic approach to using the relative performance of stocks versus numerous metrics to help you focus on most technically heathly stocks in the strongest sectors. And P&F gives clear breakout and breakdown points and levels that help with Stage Analysis.
But also the numerous ways of using P&F charts with market breadth data, some of which I've shown over the years on here. i.e. the Percentage of stocks above their moving averages, and the bullish percent indexes etc.
With regards to my custom P&F charts, I find that they give similar signals to the various AD charts. i.e divergences etc. But the clearest signals are often in the daily data itself. For example extreme days in the number of breakouts or breakdowns that tie in with other things happening in the other breadth charts and price charts themselves. But at it's most simple level it gives me a simple risk on or risk off signal based on whether it's above it's 20 day MA or not, which gives me reason to tighten stops and consider taking profits.
isatrader
Fate does not always let you fix the tuition fee. She delivers the educational wallop and presents her own bill - Reminiscences of a Stock Operator.
Fate does not always let you fix the tuition fee. She delivers the educational wallop and presents her own bill - Reminiscences of a Stock Operator.